Showing posts with label story time. Show all posts
Showing posts with label story time. Show all posts

Saturday, April 19, 2008

Why Nativists Can't Win Elections


In the last couple of years some of the anti-immigration activists have been stumped. They are louder and clearly have a larger presence in the media and internet than pro-migrant individuals. Yet, during election time they keep being beaten. Why is that? I’m going to start a series of posts trying to explain this for them.

I have pleasure of being related to a nativist. The irony is we have family members who are undocumented, he just doesn’t know it. His wife knows it and has been keeping it from him for years. He always votes for a nativist yet his wife always votes for someone who is pro-migrant. She usually finds an excuse. Mostly about the environment and how that’s her number one issue (which infuriates her husband who doesn’t believe in global warming). She hides the fact that some of her family members are undocumented from him. It’s easy to do, because like most nativists he doesn’t look beyond the Hispanic day laborer. His complaints aren’t necessarily about undocumented immigrants but directed towards Hispanics. I had to smile to myself last thanksgiving when he got into an argument with his sister on immigration and pointed to his wife’s family (my family) that all did it the “right way”.

If you asked his wife what her top issue was, she wouldn’t admit to it being immigration even though it clearly is. That’s the difference between the pros and the antis. The antis can’t wait to tell a pollster that their number one issue is immigration. Pros rarely admit to it.

Before you judge my relatives remember my relative cares about her family, enough to lie to her husband about it to protect them. You may ask yourself why did she marry such a man? He wasn’t always this way, and he’s a good husband to her and politics and bigotry aside he not a bad man. In fact he was a supporter of immigrants rights until his idol Rush (that’s right he’s one of them) started his half baked crusade against migrants. She made a decision to protect her family members and hide it from her husband. I know it wasn’t easy for her to make that decision but it has been easy to keep up. He has no idea and why would he when he thinks all undocumented immigrants are day laborers and fast food workers. I don’t think she will ever tell him, even after her last family member adjusts to a legal status. Somehow I doubt she’s alone in this situation.

See Also: Office Lunch

Monday, March 24, 2008

Story Time! - Office Lunch


Most of my friends tend to be the children of immigrnats. So, I'm going to share some of our experiences in a new "segment" I've called Story Time!. I'm a horrible story teller and I know I don't do the original 3Am phone call justice so bear with me.

Last month a good friend of mine got a new job as an upper level type manager. She was an outside hire and to smooth things over with her new employees some of whom were passed over for the position she just received she took them all out to lunch. She was horrified to find the topic turning to politics over lunch and even more so when one woman started ranting about illegal immigration.

My friend is a former undocumented immigrant and most of her family members are still undocumented (the story behind her circumstances will be saved for another time). All of a sudden 2 of the other women and a man at the table started giggling and exchanging looks. My friend started to wonder if they knew about her situation.

One of the giggling women admitted her boyfriend was an undocumented immigrant. My friend and the ranting woman were both horrified but for completely different reasons. Growing up in an undocumented family you were taught to NEVER tell anyone about the situation. To do so was to put their existence at risk. As much as my friend wanted to tell the ranting woman that she used to be an undocumented immigrant, she didn't because the last thing she needed was to expose her family to a nativist. She envied and disapproved of the woman who had outed her boyfriend. She envied her because her point had been much more effective than any polite argument my friend had put forth in humanizing undocumented immigrants. At the same time the woman's disregard for her boyfriend's safety in outing him to a nativist horrified her.

That is the fine line many people walk. The best way to humanize undocumented immigrants is to put a face on them but by doing so we put them in jeopardy. Most people would rather protect their loved ones than make a point and I can't blame them.